Reply Listing

Current topic: Working with Adults
Current Question:
Current Question Dyslexic Students
I am in shock at the amount of 'seemingly' dyslexic students I come across.

Some of these students are doing courses at level 3 and were doing fine. It seems since they were 'diagnosed' as dyslexic their confidence went down the pan. They also use their 'alleged dyslexia' as an excuse for finding the course challenging, difficult at times. Who said it was going to be easy?

Some people are in clear need of extra support and a diagnosis is necessary. I suspect that there are other cases where the diagnosis is counterproductive; it lowers student confidence and gives him/her a justification not to succeed in their course. 'I'm dyslexic they can't expect me to hand in my work on time!!!'

Somebody recently suggested to me I may be dyslexic. I asked them to go and look for something better to do, perhaps something more motivational.

Am I the only one experiencing this?
Posted: Wed Apr 1st, 2009 0:00 p.m.
  Author:
Celso
Reply Post Reply

One Reply

Message Posted
I HAVE ONLY JUST SPOTTED THIS POST ON THE FORUM, HENCE THIS RATHER TARDY REPLY. I HAVE A NEPHEW WHO IS DYSLEXIC, BUT HAS A FIRST DEGREE IN ART AND AN MA. THE FACT THAT HE HASN'T GOT A JOB IS DOWN MORE TO HIS ATTITUDE THAN THE DYSLEXIA. COULD IT BE THAT WE THINK THERE ARE MORE DYSLEXIC STUDENTS ABOUT THAN THERE USED TO BE BECAUSE WE HAVE BECOME MORE AWARE OF IT. WHEN I WAS GROWING UP, THE ATTITUDE TOWARDS DYSLEXIA - AND MANY OTHER CONDITIONS, FOR THAT MATTER - WAS SUMMED UP BY THE MOTHER (PLAYED BY THORA HIRD ) IN ONE OF ALAN BENNETTS PLAYS WHO SAYS TO HER SON "THERE WEREN'T NO DYSLEXIA WHEN YOU WERE AT SCHOOL - YOU SAT AT THE BACK AND DID RAFFIA!" AS SOMEONE WHO SUFFERS FROM A SPEECH DEFECT, I RECOGNISE THE SCENARIO - AT SCHOOL IN THE 1950'S, ALL OF US WHO WERE IN ANY WAY "DIFFERENT" WERE REGARDED AS "BACKWARD" AND MY MOTHER LIVED IN FEAR OF ME BEING SENT TO THE "SPECIAL SCHOOL" WHERE THE "DAFT" KIDS WENT - SO, NO, I DON'T THINK THERE IS MORE DYSLEXIA ABOUT, JUST THAT WE ARE MORE AWARE OF IT. MY FIRST BOSS WHEN I STARTED IN THE CAREERS SERVICE IN THE 1970'S REGARDED DYSLEXIA AS A MIDDLE - CLASS EXCUSE FOR THEIR CHILDREN NOT BEING VERY CLEVER - MIND YOU, HE ONCE TOLD ME THAT I DIDN'T HAVE A STAMMER, WHEN I MANIFESTLY DID AND DO, AND HE GOT (METAPHORICALLY SPEAKING!) BOTH BARRELS.

COLIN MARSH
Reply Post Reply
Wed Nov 25th, 2009 11:26 a.m.
 
COLIN MARSH
Post a reply to this question
Back to list of questions
Back to list of topics
Register
Home2
Mailshare
Bookshop
ICG Positional Statements and wider research
Online Application Form
Workshop Proposal Form

Copyright © 2010 Institute of Career Guidance

 

www.intergage.co.uk